Head-to-head comparison of two Minecraft servers. ButterSMP is a SMP server and MelonMC is a Java server. Real-time data updated Oct 23, 2026.
MelonMC leads with 1,466 votes and 41 active players compared to ButterSMP's 1 votes and 0 players.
| Feature | ButterSMP | MelonMC |
|---|---|---|
| IP Address | ButterSMP.aternos.me | bmsl.melonmc.org |
| Status | ● Online | ● Online |
| Players Online | 0/20 | 41/160 |
| Total Votes | 1 | 1,466 |
| Votes This Month | 0 | 1,465 |
| 7-Day Uptime | 100.0% | 100.0% |
| Game Mode | SMP | Java |
| Platform | java | java |
| Version | Latest | 1.21-26.2 |
| Cracked | No | No |
| Bedrock Support | No | No |
| Location | Unknown | US |
MelonMC has more active players right now with 41 online compared to ButterSMP's 0. MelonMC supports up to 160 concurrent players while ButterSMP supports 20.
ButterSMP has received 1 total votes (0 this month), while MelonMC has 1,466 total votes (1,465 this month). MelonMC is currently gaining more community support.
Over the past 7 days, ButterSMP maintained 100.0% uptime and MelonMC maintained 100.0% uptime. Both servers show comparable reliability.
ButterSMP: java Edition, premium only, version Latest.
MelonMC: java Edition, premium only, version 1.21-26.2.
MelonMC leads with 1,466 votes and 41 active players compared to ButterSMP's 1 votes and 0 players.
ButterSMP is a SMP server (java, Latest) with 1 votes. MelonMC is a Java server (java, 1.21-26.2) with 1,466 votes.
ButterSMP has 0 players online. MelonMC has 41 players online. Player counts are refreshed every 5 minutes.
This is a detailed comparison between ButterSMP and MelonMC, two popular Minecraft servers. ButterSMP is a SMP server with IP address ButterSMP.aternos.me running on java Edition, while MelonMC is a Java server with IP address bmsl.melonmc.org running on java Edition.
In terms of community support, ButterSMP has received 1 total votes (0 this month) compared to MelonMC's 1,466 total votes (1465 this month). MelonMC leads in community votes.
For player activity, ButterSMP currently has 0/20 players online with 100.0% weekly uptime, while MelonMC has 41/160 players with 100.0% uptime. Both servers can be joined for free through the Minecraft multiplayer menu.
Looking for more comparisons? Browse our SMP server directory, check the full server leaderboard, or explore trending Minecraft servers this week.
